So very pleased that we all pay appropriate attention to our poop schedules. So as a supportive friend, I’ll give you more reading fodder as you squeeze out your daily turds.
As usual, Crapswell had a pretty stupid request asking for position rankings. Does he know that he can get this on just about any website? That said, I’m probably more of an idiot to oblige such a request. So shown below are MY rankings of a few positions. I'll hit up the other positions later.
Quarterbacks:
1. Derek Carr [Fresno State] – Great arm, touch, and leadership. But did not shine in bowl game versus USC, as offensive line struggled to give him clear throwing lanes and time.
2. Johnny Manziel [Texas A&M] – Amazing elusiveness and playmaking ability. But might need a simplified offense scheme, as he struggles to make appropriate reads.
3. Teddy Bridgewater [Louisville] – Technically sound and in-pocket movement. But more of a system QB, who played poor competition, and took the safe and short passes way too often.
4. Blake Bortles [Central Florida] – Great poise in the pocket and is probably the safest QB in the draft. But lacks any wow factor, and I’m not sure if he has ever took over a game at UCF.
5. Zach Mettenberger [LSU] – Best arm of the draft, and improved his QB IQ under Cam Cameron at LSU. But due to his ACL tear and one-year wonder tag, he could take a tumble in the draft.
6. Brett Smith [Wyoming] – Think Johnny Football, but with a better arm and size. But without a combine invite, poor supporting cast, and coming out of Wyoming… scouts will have to sell him.
Tight Ends:
1. Eric Ebron [North Carolina] – With great athleticism and ability to stretch the field, Mayock compares him to Vernon Davis. But his ability to catch in traffic and in-line blocking need work.
2. Austin Seferian-Jenkins [Washington] – Great size, length, blocking, and catching in traffic… he is the perfect in-line TE, which is a rarity in today’s NFL. He lacks Amaro’s stats or Ebron’s 40 time.
3. Colt Lyerla [Oregon] – It could have been Lyerla at the top of this crazy stacked list of TEs, that’s how good he is. But a cocaine possession arrest and a messy off-the-field history, UDFA?
4. Troy Niklas [Notre Dame] – Lightning strikes twice, as here is another in-line TE that could light up the league. Though with only two years of work at TE he is raw, but is Kyle Rudolph-esque.
5. Jace Amaro [Texas A&M] – I won’t say anything good about this guy. Coming out of a pass-happy offense, and a defense optional conference, he is overhyped. He is a very poor move TE.
6. Xavier Grimble [USC] – A classic 5-star recruit that underachieved at USC, due to getting lost in the talent-filled offense that did not feature TEs. He’s my dark-horse long-shot in this class.
Defensive Ends (Classic 4-3 DE):
1. Jadeveon Clowney [South Carolina] – His last 12 months have mirrored that of Quinton Coples, two years prior. Supremely talented stud that took a shit on the field for his last collegiate year.
2. Scott Crichton [Oregon State] – I am a huge fan of this guy. He was constantly double-teamed and has an insane motor. I am eager to see how his arm length and broad jump will measure up.
3. Kony Ealy [Missouri] – Prototypical height/weight combination, and is accompanied by pretty decent statistics. But reading between the lines, I think he is being elevated in a week DE class.
Defensive Ends (5-Technique, 3-4 DE):
1. Ra’Shede Hageman [Minnesota] – Unique combination of size, length, strength, and athleticism. If he is put into an attacking odd front, he could be JJ Watt… otherwise he’ll be mediocre.
2. Taylor Hart [Oregon] – For a 5T DE, he put up amazing tackle numbers. Which only speaks to his ability read, react, and shed blocks. Keeping things in perspective, he should be a 3rd round pick.
3. Stephon Tuitt [Notre Dame] – Tuitt failed to add positive bulk to his frame. In 2013, he was fat, lazy, and a non-factor. That said, he’ll likely get a pass on 2013 and teams will draft off of 2012 game tape.
Safeties:
1. Calvin Pryor [Louisville] – Huge fan of this guy. I choose to trust that his domination is more so due to his ability, than the lack of talent offenses Louisville played. He is a stat sheet filler.
2. Haha Clinton-Dix [Alabama] – If he has a good combine, I think he could be a 1st rounder. That said, he seldom made splash plays. Which could be due to a conservative scheme, but no sure.
3. Hakeem Smith [Louisville] – I have seen enough of Louisville games to know that Smith is solid against the pass and the run. I don’t know if any other eligible safeties cover as well.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSo there's no RB's worth mentioning? Thanks for giving the list the newshoo watering down and cynical approach. You can't find that on every website
ReplyDeleteI think he's only doing a couple position groups at a time...
DeleteCarr as #1? Really Gow? Have you read this: http://www.rotoworld.com/articles/cfb/45952/349/out-of-the-box
DeleteYou knock Teddy for short passes but Carr looks to have thrown even more of his passes on short routes, and did so with less accuracy. And he's pretty god awful against any blitzes/pressure.
I'm really surprised with this rank.
Overall, I would rate all the top 4 QBs in the same range (about 10th to 20th) overall in a typical draft class. That's not where they'll be picked in this year's draft, but that provides perspective on overall value. Now the order of the four guys is more of my preference between QBs that I think are basically the same value. As for the article, I am a fan of stats... but Rotoworld did an awful job providing a proper qualitative analysis.
DeleteOkay, why I prefer Carr over Bridgewater: Bridgewater was supported by a far superior running game and a defense that dominated opponents. He was seldom under duress, as his offensive line was no match for defenders, and he had the luxury of a play-action offense to keep defenders honest. But Carr's right arm had to win games with little help, part of that was due to scheme, the rest was due to an embarrasing defense. Also during Carr's senior season, the new head coach installed an offense that used quick-hitting bubble screens as a primary component of the offense. This obviously led to the short distance throws Rotoworld was reporting. The year prior, Carr's old HC had a pro-style offenese that allowed Carr to stretch the field... which showed off his arm strength and decision-making. Finally, as many draft experts have said... I have concern over his less-than optimal build thinking he won't hold up well. Also, his personality is so timid that I question his ability to lead.
Regarding Clowney... are we at all concerned about his low Bench Press reps? I heard a punter beat him out.
ReplyDeleteMy choices for the Vikings at #8 right now are:
1. Teddy
2. Clowney
3. Mack
4. Manziel
5. Trade back
I don't want them to trade up for anyone but Teddy. If none of those guys are available, I hope the push for the OT's and WR's generates some value for #8 and Spielman can move into the teens to get more picks.
I'm a little gunshy with all these QB's and wouldn't mind them not taking one until at least 2nd round. In that scenario, I think I'd prefer Mettenberger, simply because he's probably a 1st Rounder without the injury.
Given our coaching hires, I would be happy with defense in round one and a QB like Mettenberger in round 2. I don't think Clowney or Mack will be there at #8 though. Hopefully, Spielman has learned from Ponder not to reach early on a QB.
DeleteI'll apply a counter argument (go figure) to Mack. In Zimmer's 4-3 defense, I see Mack as a SAM LB... not so much a DE. Last year, Zimmer's 6 rostered DEs averaged 6'5" and 280lbs, headlined by Carlos Dunlap and Michael Johnson. Mack is 6'2"ish and 250, and I'm not sure if he is worth a 8th overall pick as a SAM LB. As a 3-4 OLB, I think his potential could be "elite".
DeleteThis sounds super creepy (or porny?) if you were posting this on any non-football site:
ReplyDeleteScott Crichton [Oregon State] – I am a huge fan of this guy. He was constantly double-teamed and has an insane motor. I am eager to see how his arm length and broad jump will measure up.
Okay you caught me. I write x-rated stories in my free time.
Delete